| Digital Imaging Workflow |
|
Digital
imaging opens a world of possibilities for the university photographer:
speedy turnaround, reduced materials costs, instant proofing, and print
quality as high or higher than film. Digital imaging also brings with
it some unique challenges, as the photographer takes on more
responsibility for the final reproduction quality, as well as the
archiving of digital images.
Images are 'pre-scanned'
For the photographer who's been shooting and scanning film for reproduction, shooting with a digital camera is great: all your images come 'pre-scanned.' This saves the time you spent waiting for the processor, waiting for the film to dry, editing rolls and rolls of film, paging it all, and scanning the selected images. On the other hand, for those of you who are shooting slides, dropping the film at the lab, and giving the selected slides to your clients, shooting digital makes you the processing lab. This can add a significant amount of time to each assignment. Overwhelming volume of images
In either case, shooting digital has some disadvantages. First, there is no film as a backup. If the hard drive crashes, or the compact flash card is unreadable, everything is gone. (This is like having the lab run all the film through the wrong chemistry.) Second is the problem of editing all those images. It’s not reasonable to open them one-by-one in Photoshop, not if there are 300 images from one assignment. Third is the question of keeping track of the images so they can be found again next week, or next year, or even further down the road. Complicating all of this is the sheer volume of images -- it's like trying to drink from a fire hose. Because of the nature of shooting with a digital camera, it's very easy to shoot several thousand images per week, all of which need to be edited, captioned, archived, and made available to clients. The good news is that with a well-designed workflow, the digital monster can be tamed. Determining user requirements
The first thing to do is to decide in advance exactly how the digital images will be used, both now and in the future. When Wake Forest hosted a presidential debate in October 2000, I had the good fortune to borrow a then-new D-30 digital camera from Canon. I expected to shoot film for the majority of my assignments that week, and use the D-30 to shoot occasional feature images for the web. Instead, after one look at the image quality from the camera, I ended up shooting more than 1500 digital images in under 3 days, and relegated film to a backup role. After
sending the camera back to Canon, I realized that I was completely
overwhelmed with my pictures. I was determined to create an efficient
system for handling all aspects of digital imaging before we purchased
our own camera. I had several requirements for the system:
• Save every original file for possible future needs,
• Easily and quickly edit the entire shoot,
• Permanently attach usable caption and other information to each file,
• Save selected images in an easily-accessible archive.
In
addition, I wanted the digital workflow to blend in seamlessly with my
current filing and billing system. I didn't want to have to use two
completely separate systems for film and digital imaging.
There
are three major areas to deal with when designing a digital workflow:
editing and captioning your images, storing the images from each
assignment, and creating a usable archive of images.
Editing the take
This requires a piece of specialized software called an image browser, which displays a folder full of images and allows renaming, editing, ranking, and captioning. Recent versions of Photoshop include the Adobe Bridge program, which works as a simple browser and has the advantage of being linked to Photoshop. Most digital cameras also come with a browsing application, though in many cases they are slow and leave much to be desired. An
image browser has a limited feature set: it won’t process RAW files
(though a few do), it won’t catalog photos (though some will), and it
won’t make complicated web galleries. A good browser is fast: fast at
showing a large preview, fast at renaming and captioning, and fast at
selecting the good photos and ranking or tagging them. There are
several outstanding third-party image browsers: Photo Mechanic, ACDSee
Pro, iView Media Pro, and BreezeBrowser are but a few.
A
new category of Digital Workflow Applications came into being in late
2005 with the release of Apple’s Aperture program, which allows the
photographer to download, edit, process, print, make web galleries, and
catalog all of his or her digital photos. Adobe quickly released the
beta version of Lightroom, an application with very similar features.
Initial reviews of Aperture were mixed, but Apple has a history of
creating great software (see Final Cut Pro). Lightroom is still in
beta, and won’t be released until late 2006, but it will be available
for both Mac and Windows platforms. I have worked with Lightroom, and
been impressed with the general feel of the application.
For the last five years, I have used Photo Mechanic, from Camerabits.
Photo Mechanic
Photo Mechanic is a fast, well-designed image browser. PM handles JPEG and RAW files from any source, opening your images in a window that looks like a light table full of slides. From this window, you can rename the photo files, rotate the thumbnails, open a full-screen preview, add caption information, and open them in Photoshop. Did I mention that it is fast? The Photo Mechanic Contact Sheet WindowPhoto
Mechanic can rename and caption a group of images all at the same time.
Any digital assignment results in lots of images with the same caption
info - there might be 20 images of the university president speaking at
graduation, 50 of the commencement speaker, 10 of her getting hooded,
and 30 more of the procession. PM can batch-rename groups of images
with useful filenames, and attached real caption information with all
the IPTC fields (byline, dateline, caption, lots of other stuff.) All
of this information is permanently attached to the file, and is
available under the 'File Info' window in Photoshop. As of version 4.4,
Photo Mechanic adds IPTC information within many RAW file formats on
both Windows and Macintosh computers.
The Photo Mechanic IPTC Stationery Pad:One
well-designed feature of Photo Mechanic is the ‘Ingest’ function, which
is a customizable download system that allows me to rename and caption
each image as it is downloaded from the card.
The Photo Mechanic Ingest Dialog BoxIn
my workflow, I use the Ingest function to download my photos from the
memory card to a folder on my hard drive. While they are being
Ingested, the photos are renamed and captioned, and copied to a backup
folder at the same time. Note the extensive use of variables in the
Ingest and IPTC Stationery Pad (the variables are in {} brackets).
After ingesting the card(s), I open the Contact Sheet, add any
additional caption information to specific pictures that require it,
and start looking at large previews to decide which images are worth
keeping. These are Tagged, and the rest are sent to the Trash Can.
A Word About Captioning
Why caption everything? It's not just to be able to identify the subjects, although that's important. Digital images end up everywhere - all over the internet, on CDs full of printed images, on the hard drives of people everywhere. The IPTC captions should give the end user information about who shot and who owns the rights to the image, as well as contact information. Also, since the images can exist outside of the local filing system and without any printed hard copy, it's important to have complete information about the contents of the image attached electronically. There is no time better than when the images are first downloaded from the camera: every hour reduces the amount of information that can be added to the file. After
renaming and captioning, the photos are edited for keepers, which are
then opened in Photoshop directly from the Photo Mechanic window. Then
they are ready to be sent to the client with full caption info
attached. (Note that using the 'Save For Web' option in Photoshop will
strip all metadata such as IPTC and EXIF fields. So captions won't
appear on those files.)
Saving digital images
At this point in the process I have a folder on my hard drive with all the photos that I shot from my assignment, all with usable filenames and caption information. In addition, I have selected or tagged several images from the shoot for processing and archiving. No more CDs
I used to burn each assignment onto CD-R media and file it along with the job paperwork, just like film assignments. No more. Since all my assignments are now shot digitally, I save my pictures on hard drives, in folders with the job name saved inside a dated folder for each day. One hard drive is in the photo studio, on a server that I can access from anywhere with a high-speed connection. The other hard drive is in the Creative Services office, in another building on campus, accessible through our campus ethernet system. I back up all my digital files to both servers for ease of access and security. One advantage of this system is that our staff designers can have read-only access to one of the servers, so they can see everything I shoot very quickly after the assignment is complete. Finally, I keep an third set of backup drives off-site. Creating a usable archive
Having all my RAW files on the server doesn’t really help anyone, since the designers and web developers are not able to use RAW files in their work. I need an easily-accessible archive of processed photos, available to anyone in the department at any time. There
are several good database programs for photographers, including Canto
Cumulus, Extensis Portfolio, and iView Media Pro. It’s also possible to
write a database using Filemaker or Access, or to program a web-based
archive. Several of the commercial applications, including Cumulus, are
available as client/server versions, and Cumulus has a web module
available that puts the entire archive 'live' on the web, fully
searchable.
We
have chosen to use Canto Cumulus, and have implemented the Cumulus
Workgroup client/server system. For a complete review of the system,
see the Archiving Page elsewhere on this site.
The formal workflow
This is the written workflow that I have posted over my work station: • Ingest
each card into a folder on my desktop. The folder gets the jobname,
which is a short 6-8 character identifier. Each file is renamed using a
specific naming convention of ‘YYYYMMDDjobnameFNUM.CR2’ where YYYMMDD
is the shoot date, jobname is the same as the folder name, and FNUM is
the 4-digit frame number generated by the camera. Each file gets a
generic caption, including most of the IPTC information. All of this is
generated automatically in Photo Mechanic.
• Open
the folder in a Photo Mechanic Contact Sheet window. Open the large
preview window, and quickly work through every image, tagging those
that I want to save. Close the preview, select the untagged photos, and
delete them. Add specific additional caption information to any image
that requires it.
• Re-open the large preview window, and carefully select any images that I want to process into the archive.
• Still
working inside Photo Mechanic, select the images to be processed, and
press Apple-E to open them in Photoshop. The Adobe Camera Raw window
opens. Tweak each photo in ACR, then click ‘Done.’
• Back
inside Photo Mechanic, use the ‘Send to Droplet’ command to process the
photos as needed for archive and web use. The Droplets are automated
macros created within Photoshop that process, sharpen, and save images
in various sizes and color spaces as needed.
• Close the Photo Mechanic contact sheet, and copy the job folder to the server.
This works well for my purposes. Feel free to adapt this for your own use.
|



